Brown Fisheries Fish House

32520 W M-123, Paradise, MI 49768, United States
$$$ Seafood restaurant
(50 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

Welcome to Brown Fisheries Fish House, the quintessential seafood destination nestled in the picturesque town of Paradise, MI. Known for its outstanding fresh catch from the bountiful waters of Whitefish Bay, this charming eatery is a must-visit for seafood lovers and anyone looking to enjoy a taste of local flavor.

As you approach the restaurant, you may be struck by its unassuming exterior, but don’t let that discourage you. This local gem is renowned for serving the best Whitefish around—an essential experience for anyone visiting this beautiful region. Reviews from satisfied customers sing praises of their Whitefish sandwiches, which are perfectly grilled and served on a soft bun. Pair that with their crunchy French fries and homemade coleslaw, and you have a meal that will linger in your memory long after the last bite.

The dining atmosphere is casual and welcoming, perfect for families and friends. With outdoor picnic tables set up under the shade of trees, you can enjoy your meal while soaking in the fresh air and breathtaking views of the surrounding nature. The restaurant also has a unique ordering system that adds to the experience—during these unusual times, you can conveniently place your order at the window and enjoy your feast right from your car, or opt for the laid-back vibe of dining outdoors, just like our loyal patrons.

Customers rave about the freshness and quality of the fish, with one satisfied diner describing Brown Fisheries Fish House as “the best place in Paradise to get a really fresh caught Whitefish Basket.” It’s clear that the daily catch here means every piece of fish served is not just a meal but a celebration of local seafood culture. Many have declared that if you travel to Paradise and miss out on this culinary experience, you might as well have missed the entire point of your visit!

Compelling stories from the community add to the charm of this restaurant. One patron reminisced fondly about their family cabin and how they’d frequent Brown Fisheries Fish House. It’s that kind of nostalgic connection that keeps the locals and visitors alike coming back for more, solidifying this spot as a beloved fixture in the area.

In summary, whether you're a dedicated seafood aficionado or simply someone craving a delicious meal made with local ingredients, **Brown Fisheries Fish House** delivers on all fronts. With its fresh, mouthwatering offerings, friendly service, and inviting atmosphere, it promises to be a highlight of your time in Paradise. Don’t just drive by; make sure to indulge in the culinary delight that awaits you at this one-of-a-kind eatery!

Service options
Offers takeout
Serves dine-in
No delivery
50 Reviews
Debra NAPIERALSKI

15 Sep 2025

Fantastic fresh Whitefish, good crunchy French fries and Coleslaw. Because of Covid you order at the window and it's delivered to your car. We opted to eat at the picnic tables outside. It's really no wonder it gets high reviews for their fish, don't drive by because of its looks stop and eat.

Jakob Cook

05 Sep 2025

Best Whitefish sandwich in Paradise! Thoroughly enjoyed the sandwich and fries. Both kids ate their Whitefish too, like it was going out of style. Good food and friendly service. Loved the history of the place too.

Andrew Kinnard

17 Aug 2025

If you travel to Paradise and don't eat (or get takeout) here, you messed up (or hate fish [and shouldn't be wasting time reading reviews of a fish joint]). You're getting daily catch whitefish in a town on Whitefish Bay. Best fish and chips since England! We always get fish sandwiches and take them to our favorite picnic spot on the Bay.

Sherolyn Smith

26 Jul 2025

Still the best place in Paradise to get a really fresh caught Whitefish Basket!

Christine Reader

23 Jul 2025

This place used to be the place to go for fish! We had a cabin up there and we’d eat there about 3-4 times when we were up there! It’s a shame it hasn’t opened guess the kids don’t have the same zest for good food as their parents did!!!

Michelle Giraud

20 Jul 2025

The whitefish is amazing! Fried to perfection nice crunch. Waitresses were awesome. We made it just before they ran out of fish, so go early!!

Join the Brown Fisheries Fish House Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.